Posted by
sarah on Mar 7, 2012 in
Food |
1 comment
In case you haven’t been following my blog posts this week, I’ve been living in hamantashen hell. Maybe a slight exaggeration but pretty close to it.
A couple weeks ago, my fiance traveled to Tel Aviv for business. While researching restaurants and dried fruit stores in the city, we came across an article published in the New York Times about modern flavours of hamantashen and this Tel Aviv bakery who was spicing up the holiday cookie.
Upon his return, we came up with the idea that we should jointly bake hamantashen for Purim and get in the festive mood. The problem was that neither of us have made hamantashen since we were eight years old, so we had to first locate a recipe suitable for experimentation. I had a big bag of poppy seeds sitting around on my counter so I flipped through some cookbooks and Googled “poppy seed hamantashen recipe” to get some ideas. We decided to narrow our selection down to three recipes and bake three batches to see which one was the best.
During my preliminary research, I came across two comical posts from Smitten Kitchen (here & here) sharing her experiences in making these fun haman’s hat cookies. (Not soo easy) I also found some enticing recipes from the New York Times Hamantashen with Poppy Seed Filling, Seattle Times Orange Poppy Seed Hamantashen and Epicurious’s Traditional Hamantashen recipe. We planned it all out: One hamantashen recipe a day for three days and then taste test.
Here are the results:
#1 Traditional Hamantashen recipe from Epicurious:
This dough was falling apart. It was cracking, dry and crumbly. I ended up adding more liquid (orange juice) just to get it to hold together. I also burnt the first batch because my oven was hotter than the recipe, so I ended up reducing the time to 10 min on the second batch which worked out better. These hamantashen tasted good (I used apricot jam from the jar because I was so frustrated with the dough and wanted the experience to come to an end) but this recipe was a pain.
#2 NY Times Hamantashen Recipe:
A much better recipe than the Epicurious recipe but the dough was still quite crumbly and hard to work with. I did like the fact that the recipe called for butter instead of shortening and liked the powdered sugar instead of regular sugar. After mixing all the ingredients, the dough seemed to have a nice consistency but for some reason, it still broke apart. This cookie had a lemon flavour instead of orange rind and juice which worked well with my thick apricot jam filling. Half way through baking, I tried a looser cherry jam upon my fiance’s request, and these things literally exploded in the oven and came out as red blobs, plastered to the baking sheet. Conclusion: The dough was not strong enough to handle a more liquid filling. Close but no cigar- still tasty though.
#3 Kinnereth Cookbook (and the winner)- The perfect dough recipe. It was moist, easy to roll and the edges stayed smooth on the cookies. As for the filling, I had to do some major alterations to the poppy seed mixture to get it to a thicker consistency. I ended up adding dates and walnuts on top of the lemon juice, honey and sugar. (recipe below). If I were to make this recipe again, I would add lemon or orange rind to the dough for just a hint of flavour since right now the dough is rather plain. However, I’ll take plain with a hint of sweet over crumbling, disaster dough any day.
From the Kinnereth Cookbook
For Cookie Dough:
3 cups all purpose flour
3 teaspoons baking powder
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/4 teaspoon salt
3/4 cup butter
3 eggs
1 egg beaten for brushing dough
Preheat oven to 400F or 200C. Sift flour, baking powder, sugar and salt together. Cut in butter. Beat in eggs and mix to a soft dough. Roll out on a floured board to 1/4″ in thickness. Cut with a round cookie cutter or glass. Spoon desired filling in the centre and pinch circle together to form a triangle shape. Brush with beaten egg and place on a baking sheet with parchment paper. Bake for 12-15 min. Mine only needed 10 minutes to come out golden but it depends on your oven.
Poppy Seed Filling:
1/2 pound of poppy seeds (225 grams)
1/2 cup honey
juice and rind of 1/2 lemon
1/2 cup granulated sugar
I added 6 dates and 1/3 cup of walnuts (play around with quantity)
Scald poppy seeds with boiling water two or three times. This tripped me up. I boiled water, soaked the poppy seeds and put them in the food processor to grind. It didn’t work. There was still too much liquid. I read that putting them through a coffee grinder (unsoaked) is better than a food processor but I did not try this method. Basically blend all the ingredients together until you have a pseudo-paste that can hold its shape on the dough. If it is too liquid, you risk hamantashen overflow or explosion, so pay attention to the consistency.
You really could fill these cookies with just about anything like stewed apples, cherries, prunes, dates, jam, or chocolate. Be creative. It’s the dough that makes or breaks the recipe.
And so our story ends with hamantashen for all. I am retiring my hamantashen baking until next March. If you are feeling ambitious and want to try a recipe, let me save you from hardship. Stick with the Kinnereth!!!!
|
1 comment